• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Lake City Creamery and Coffee – Premium Ice Cream & Friendly Service in Celina, OH

Lake City Creamery and Coffee in Celina, Ohio, is a beloved local gem known for its rich, creative ice cream flavors and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Renowned for rotating seasonal varieties like Blue Moon, Birthday Cake, and unique creations such as the Celebration shake, this creamery delights both kids and adults alike. Generous portions and friendly, personable service elevate the experience, making it a favorite stop for families and travelers. Highlights like the Buckeye and Snickers Latte sundaes showcase their inventive approach to classic desserts. With its charming setting and consistently exceptional offerings, Lake City Creamery and Coffee is truly a standout destination for ice cream lovers.

Lake City Creamery and Coffee at a glance

  • Address 5465 OH-29, Celina, OH 45822, United States
  • Phone +1 419-268-2489
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Lake City Creamery and Coffee: Reviews & Ratings

Chantelle Mcintire
5

“I have never been here before except this once. But I would give it 10 stars. They do really good ice cream.”- a direct quote from my seven year-old . Ice cream was great. Service was wonderful. Very cute place with a huge selection. One wall was a chalkboard for the kids. As a tired mom, I also give 10 stars

Lucas Broering
5

My favorite ice cream place in the area. Their ice cream is genuinely some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had, and there’s not much else to say. They rotate flavors, and have some amazing seasonal flavors. Their blue moon and birthday cake are my favorite staple favorites, plus the Celebration shake which is a combo of those two and some marshmallow creme, and their Peepalicious, Purple Cow, Overzealous Birthday Cake, etc. are some of the most amazing rotating flavors I’ve had. Plus, really friendly staff, good atmosphere, and good food hygiene. Genuinely just spectacular ice cream.

James Compton
5

We have been coming here for many years and love the great customer service and the ice cream too. The owner is very personable and his flavors are creative and everchanging. The portions are always very generous too. Whenever we pass through here we love to stop. It might be my favorite ice cream parlor we go to.

Morgan Noffsinger
5

I had the brownie sundae with snickers latte ice cream and my husband had the buckeye sundae and they were both so good! Definitely going to go back with the kids! Highly recommend!

Eric Jones
5

I had a banana split and buckeye sundae, both were very good. The two ladies behind the counter were very friendly as well! Would definitely visit again if we return for another Eldora trip!

michael farris
5

I went here for some milkshakes and this place delivered. They have cool and interesting flavors. I got the cookie Monster flavor (the one on the right) and it is fire.

Denver Lively
5

Very nice ice cream shop. Nice variety and friendly service.

Andrew Beedle
5

The strawberry cheesecake cone is an experience. It is now my favorite strawberry cheesecake. The Irish whiskey milkshake is a wonderful creamy contrast. This place is special and the locals are lucky to have it. I'll definitely be back next time I go through Celina.

Location

  • Lake City Creamery and Coffee
    Lake City Creamery and Coffee
    5465 OH-29, Celina, OH 45822, United States Hotline: +1 419-268-2489

Nestled in the heart of Celina, Ohio, Lake City Creamery and Coffee offers an inviting retreat for ice cream lovers seeking both classic and inventive flavors. This charming ice cream shop at 5465 OH-29 stands out not only for its diverse menu but also for the warm, friendly atmosphere that greets every visitor.

Their gelato is a standout, creamy and rich, delighting those who crave a smoother, more refined treat. Unique offerings like the Dark Chocolate Espresso ice cream showcase their creativity, perfectly balancing bold coffee notes with deep chocolate richness. Seasonal flavors such as the whimsical Easter Peep Ice Cream capture the spirit of the moment, while staples like Banana Split and the Cookie Monster Milkshake evoke both nostalgia and indulgence.

The Frozen menu is a playground of textures and tastes. The Celebration shake, a delightful blend of blue moon, birthday cake flavors, and marshmallow creme, is inventive and satisfying, highlighting their penchant for playful yet delicious combinations. Fans of heartier options will appreciate the generous portions of sundaes like the Buckeye and brownie sundae with Snickers latte ice cream, each bite harmonizing sweet, nutty, and creamy elements. For coffee enthusiasts, the Iced Vanilla Latte complements the ice cream offerings perfectly, making it a well-rounded destination for refreshment.

What truly elevates Lake City Creamery and Coffee is more than just the menu. The staff’s warmth and attentiveness create a welcoming space where families and friends can relax and enjoy. The kid-friendly chalkboard wall fosters community and creativity, making the experience memorable beyond just the taste. Regular patrons praise the ever-changing flavors, personal touches from the owner, and high standards of hygiene. The consistency in quality and innovation ensure the shop remains a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike.

In essence, Lake City Creamery and Coffee isn’t just an ice cream shop; it’s a place where flavor meets heart. Whether you’re savoring a rich gelato or delighting in a cotton candy cone, you can expect a joyful, indulgent experience that epitomizes small-town charm mixed with exceptional culinary craftsmanship.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards